The Apothecary Diaries Review: 9 Reasons It’s the Most Underrated Anime of the Decade

I’ll be straight with you. When I first saw The Apothecary Diaries pop up in my queue, I almost skipped it. The thumbnail looked like yet another historical fantasy with a pretty girl in a palace. I’d burned out on those. I almost let this one go. That was, genuinely, one of the worst near-misses of my anime-watching year.

Three episodes later I was rearranging my weekend to finish it. By episode eight I had texted three different friends about it. And by the time the finale rolled around, I was already hunting for the light novel because I needed more and I needed it immediately.

So this isn’t one of those “I watched the first episode and it seems decent” reviews. I’ve watched the whole run, I’ve gone back and rewatched key arcs, I’ve read threads, debated theories, and absorbed a lot of the source material discussion. If you’re trying to figure out whether The Apothecary Diaries review content you’ve read so far is actually telling you the full picture — spoiler: most of it isn’t.

Let me give you the real one.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: What Actually Makes It Different

The first thing that separates The Apothecary Diaries from every other historical-setting anime is that the main character, Maomao, is not trying to fall in love. She’s not trying to climb a social ladder. She doesn’t have some tragic past that fuels a revenge arc. She just wants to do pharmacy work, understand medicine, and occasionally figure out who’s poisoning people in the imperial court. That’s it. That’s her motivation.

And somehow that’s the most refreshing character framing I’ve seen in years.

We’re so used to protagonists defined by their romantic goal or their trauma or their world-saving destiny that when someone like Maomao shows up — genuinely curious, dry as toast, mildly irritated by most social situations — it almost feels subversive. She’s not “bad at emotions as a quirk.” She just has different priorities, and the show respects that completely.

The mysteries themselves are structured more like a medical procedural than a fantasy thriller. Each arc presents a problem — a concubine is losing her hair, a baby keeps dying, a servant collapses with strange symptoms — and Maomao works through them using real apothecary logic. The show trusts you to follow along. It doesn’t over-explain or hold your hand, and that trust is something a lot of anime refuse to extend to their audience.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: Maomao — The Protagonist That Changes How You Watch the Show

I want to spend real time on Maomao because most reviews get her wrong by trying to simplify her. She gets described as “sarcastic” or “eccentric” and those words don’t capture what actually makes her interesting.

Maomao was raised by her adoptive father, a skilled physician in the red-light district. She grew up around illness, addiction, exploitation, and practical medicine. That upbringing didn’t make her cynical in the way anime usually writes cynical characters — she didn’t become cold or closed off. She became functional. She looks at problems the way a skilled tradesperson looks at a broken machine: observe, identify, fix. Emotion is a variable she accounts for, not something she’s immune to.

The show has this running thing where Maomao’s cheeks flush slightly pink when she encounters an interesting case. Not romance. Medicine. The way other characters light up around food or fighting, she lights up around toxicology. That detail alone says more about her character than a full episode of exposition would.

Her relationship with Jinshi — the court official who becomes central to the story — is also handled in a way that genuinely surprised me. He’s objectively beautiful, and every woman in the imperial court loses their head around him. Maomao finds him annoying and suspicious. Not as a tsundere setup. She’s genuinely not interested, and she’s also quietly aware that he keeps finding reasons to involve her in cases, which tells her something about his actual motivations. It’s a dynamic built on mutual calculation rather than attraction, and watching it slowly shift is one of the better slow-burns in recent memory.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: The Mystery Writing That Holds Up on Rewatches

Here’s something I tested: I went back and rewatched the first five episodes after finishing the season. The foreshadowing is astonishing. Not in a “gotcha, we hid a clue” way but in a “the show knew where it was going and laid the groundwork so carefully you can see it in retrospect” way.

The poisoning cases aren’t there just to be solved. Each one peels back something about how the imperial court actually functions — who has power, who pretends to, who’s vulnerable, what’s considered worth investigating versus worth covering up. By the time a major arc resolves, you’ve learned something about the social architecture of the setting through the investigation itself, not through an exposition dump.

That’s genuinely hard to write. Most mystery anime either front-load their worldbuilding or ignore it entirely in favor of the puzzle. The Apothecary Diaries does neither. It layers them together in a way that makes both better.

The case that hit me hardest — and I’ll stay vague to avoid spoilers — involves a mother and child in the court. The answer to what’s happening is something you could technically figure out early if you were paying close attention. But the show doesn’t make you feel stupid for not getting it. It makes you feel like you were being shown everything you needed and chose where to look. There’s a difference, and the writing knows it.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: The Supporting Cast That Actually Has Depth

I’ll name a few characters worth knowing about before you go in:

The Apothecary Diaries Review: Animation and Visual Direction

TOHO Animation handled production on this, and the visual identity is distinctive. The palette leans into ochre, deep teal, and warm reds — colors that feel historically grounded rather than the generic fantasy pastels that a lot of palace-setting anime default to. The court feels like it has a real material culture: textiles, architecture, the way light falls in different pavilions at different hours.

Character animation during dialogue scenes is unusually expressive. Maomao’s micro-expressions carry a lot of the comedy — a flicker of genuine interest when a case turns strange, the very specific face she makes when Jinshi is being annoying. These aren’t exaggerated anime reaction faces. They’re subtle, and that subtlety is actually harder to animate well.

The show doesn’t have the action-sequence budget of something like Jujutsu Kaisen or the visual spectacle of DanDaDan, and it doesn’t need it. The budget goes toward character expression and atmospheric setting, which is the right call for a story this grounded. Where the animation dips slightly — and it does, in a few transitional episodes — it’s noticeable but never ruins a scene.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: Where It Compares to Other Currently Airing Shows

People who liked Spy x Family for its mix of warmth and clever plotting tend to enjoy The Apothecary Diaries. The tone is different — Apothecary is quieter, more deliberate, less comedic in the broad sense — but the underlying craft is similar. Both shows put genuine thought into making you care about people before testing them.

Fans of monster-threat series like Kaiju No. 8 might find the pace slower going at first. But if you can sit with it, the payoff is different in kind rather than lesser in degree. Apothecary earns its emotional moments through patient accumulation, not escalation.

If your measuring stick is pure mystery plotting, this is probably the best mystery anime has produced since Hyouka. I’ll stand by that. The structural discipline is comparable, and Maomao as a detective figure is arguably more interesting than Oreki because she has genuine stakes in the outcomes she investigates.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: Pros and Cons (The Honest Version)

The Apothecary Diaries Review: What Google’s AI Summary Gets Wrong

I went and looked at what the AI-generated overviews say about this show. The consistent framing is “historical mystery romance” — and that framing creates an expectation problem. People expecting romance go in, find it’s lighter on that side than expected, and bounce. People who’d love the mystery-procedural angle don’t pick it up because it sounds like a shoujo romantic drama.

The show is closer to a period procedural with an unusual protagonist than it is a romance. The relationship element is real but secondary — it develops in the background of the case work, not instead of it. If you go in expecting something like a fantasy version of a detective series where the detective happens to be a young woman who also has someone silently pining for her on the side, you’ll be significantly closer to what’s actually there.

Also: the show has a much darker edge than the pleasant-looking art style suggests. Some of the case subjects touch on infant death, addiction (including in the specific context of the red-light district), political manipulation of vulnerable women, and the mechanics of exploitation within a hierarchical system. The show doesn’t wallow in any of it, but it doesn’t flinch either. Knowing that going in is actually useful, because the moments where the darkness surfaces land harder when you’ve been settled in the warmth of the daily-life scenes.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: Moments That Stuck With Me

Without getting into heavy spoiler territory, a few things that stayed with me after the season ended:

There’s a scene early on where Maomao is explaining to herself (via internal monologue) why she’s getting involved in a case that doesn’t require her involvement. Her official reasoning is curiosity. But the show frames it visually in a way that suggests there’s more going on — and that gap between what she says and what’s shown is a really efficient piece of character work. It tells you exactly the kind of show this is going to be.

The arc around Lady Lihua is the one I’d most want people to experience without spoilers. It starts as a conflict and ends as something significantly more complicated and, ultimately, more honest about the conditions these women are actually living in. When the resolution arrives, it’s not triumphant. It’s just true. That kind of emotional register is rare.

And the final arc of the season earns its place without overstaying. Things are left genuinely open in a way that feels intentional rather than frustrated — like you’ve read the first act of something larger rather than watched a story fail to finish itself. It made me want more in exactly the right way.

The Apothecary Diaries Review: Who Should Watch This

If you’ve ever finished a season of something and immediately wished there was more not because of cliffhangers but because you just didn’t want to leave the world and the characters — this is for you.

If you like mysteries that actually make sense in retrospect and don’t rely on the detective magically knowing things the audience couldn’t have figured out — this is for you.

If you want a female protagonist who’s fully realized without being defined by either romance or trauma — this is absolutely for you.

If you need constant action or rapid escalation to stay engaged — give it three episodes minimum before deciding. If it hasn’t clicked by episode three, it probably isn’t your speed.

But for the right viewer, The Apothecary Diaries is the kind of show that gets better the more closely you watch it, and that quality compounds over time. I came away from it with a high opinion of what anime is capable of doing with female-led narratives when the source material is treated seriously and the production cares about getting it right.

For more anime reviews and guides, check out the 9anime-tv.pro blog archive — there’s deep coverage on everything from current season picks to classic rewatches worth your time.

And if you want to start watching right now, watch anime online at 9anime-tv.pro — the full season is available and the queue runs smooth.